Tourisme et Patrimoine
Le territoire de Roquebrune-Cap-Martin
École nationale supérieure d'architecture Paris-Malaquais, LIAT
Roquebrune-Cap-Martin,
France
3rd international architecture workshop
01
> 04 September 2017: study tour from Marseille to Cap-Martin
05 > 15 September 2017: International Workshop
|
Promoted by
Designing
Heritage Tourism Landscapes
schools of architecture network
project coordinators
Maria Salerno, École nationale supérieure d'architecture
Paris-Malaquais, LIAT
Mauro Marzo, Università Iuav di Venezia, Dipartimento di Culture del
progetto
participating schools
Università di Camerino, Scuola di Ateneo di Architettura e
Design “Edoardo Vittoria” Ascoli Piceno – Università degli Studi di Catania, Struttura didattica
Speciale di Architettura, Sede di Siracusa – Universidade de
Évora, Departamento de Arquitectura – Università degli Studi di
Napoli Federico II – École Nationale Supérieure d’Architecture Paris-Malaquais – Università degli Studi di Parma – Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Facultad de Arquitectura,
Planeamiento y Diseño –
Università degli Studi Mediterranea di Reggio Calabria – Universidad de
Sevilla, Esquela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Università Iuav di Venezia
(network leader)
scientific committee of the Designing Heritage Tourism Landscapes
Network
Roberta Amirante, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II – Gustavo Carabajal,
Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Facultad de Arquitectura, Planeamiento y
Diseño – Luigi
Coccia, Università di Camerino, Scuola
di Ateneo di Architettura e Design “Edoardo Vittoria” Ascoli Piceno – Mauro Marzo, Università Iuav di Venezia – João Rocha, Universidade de Évora, Departamento de Arquitectura – Maria Salerno,
École Nationale Supérieure d’Architecture Paris-Malaquais – Antonio Tejedor
Cabrera, Universidad de Sevilla, Esquela
Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Marina Tornatora, Università degli Studi Mediterranea di Reggio Calabria,
Dipartimento dArTe
scientific committee in France for the 3rd international
workshop of the network
Maria Salerno, ENSA Paris-Malaquais – Denis
Berthelot, urban planner, association EG.EM.LC – Orfina
Fatigato, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico
II – Rafaël
Magrou, ENSA
Paris-Malaquais – Mauro Marzo, Università Iuav di Venezia – Luca
Merlini, ENSA
Paris-Malaquais – Lucie Morand, ENSA
Paris-Malaquais
patronage
Mairie de Roquebrune-Cap-Martin –
Association Eileen Gray-Etoile de Mer-Le Corbusier – Conservatoire
du Littoral – CARF – Fondation
Le Corbusier – Association Cap Moderne
professors
Roberta Amirante, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II – Renato Capozzi, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II – Luigi Coccia, Università di Camerino, Scuola di Ateneo di Architettura e Design
“Edoardo Vittoria” Ascoli Piceno – Orfina Fatigato, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II – Marco Ferrari, Università Iuav di Venezia – Ana Lina Klotzman, Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Facultad de Arquitectura,
Planeamiento y Diseño – Rafaël Magrou,
École nationale supérieure d'architecture Paris-Malaquais – Mauro Marzo, Università Iuav di Venezia – João Matos, Universidade
de Évora, Departamento de Arquitectura – Lucie Morand, École nationale supérieure d'architecture
Paris-Malaquais – Guillermo Pavón
Torrejón, Universidad
de Sevilla, Esquela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Claudia Pirina, Università degli Studi di Parma
– Julián Prieto
Fernández, Universidad de
Sevilla, Esquela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Maria Salerno, École nationale supérieure d'architecture
Paris-Malaquais – João Soares, Universidade de Évora, Departamento de Arquitectura, CHAIA – Marina Tornatora, Università degli
Studi Mediterranea di Reggio Calabria, Dipartimento dArTe – Federica Visconti, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II
co-organizing team
Viola Bertini,
Università Iuav di Venezia, Dipartimento di Culture
del progetto
tutors
Michele
Bagnato, Università degli Studi Mediterranea di
Reggio Calabria – Viola Bertini, Università Iuav di Venezia – Dijana Bukvic, Università di Camerino, Scuola di Ateneo di Architettura e Design
“Edoardo Vittoria” Ascoli Piceno – Claudia
Chirianni, Università degli
Studi di Napoli Federico II –
Sara Cipolletti, Università di
Camerino, Scuola di Ateneo di Architettura e Design “Edoardo
Vittoria” Ascoli Piceno – Olga Izzo, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II – Marina López Sánchez, Universidad de Sevilla, Esquela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Begoña Prieto Galeano, Universidad de Sevilla, Esquela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Luca Salerno, architect Paris-Milano – Francesca Talevi, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II
guest-experts
Marc
Barani, architect, Grand Prix national de
l’architecture 2013 – Tim
Benton, Professor Emeritus of Art History at the Open
University – Patrick Cesari, mayor of
Roquebrune Cap Martin – Richard Ciocchetti,
1st deputy city planning RCM – Jean–Louis Dedieu, deputy culture RCM – François Fouchier, delegate region PACA – Conservatoire du littoral –
Jean Christophe Gay, Professor at the
University Nice-Côte d’Azur – Olivier Jonquet, mayor Office Director RCM – Yves
K’Ourio, director of Space Department and
development, CARF – Luc Liogier,
Director ENSA Paris-Malaquais – Claire-Lise Mary head of Service –
Conservatoire du littoral – Luca Merlini, Professor ENSA Paris Malaquais – Soline Nivet, Associate
Professor ENSA Paris Malaquais – Michel Richard, director of the Fondation Le Corbusier – Jacques Sbriglio, architect urban planner
students
Jules
Balmes – Ana Paula Benitez Coquet –Clement Bonnet – Desirée Borella – María del Carmen Fernández Pérez – Maria Lorenza Crupi – Joseph De
Metz – Macarena Díez Alonso – Filippo Dottor – Morgane
Gernigon –
Marica Giommarini – Alessandra
Guglielmo –
Zoe Lefevre – Maria Laura Leonardi
– Rafael Luque – Francesca Mottin – Manuel Muñoz Ávalos – Matilde Nardi – Isabella Nylund – Hugo Pires – Ines Pradeau – Francisca Queiroz – Alejandra Ríos Moguer – Francisco de la Rosa – Julián Rosenfeld – Anastassia Rouchy – Bendetta
Savina – Adrián Suárez Torres – Maisa Trindade – Bogdan Ursan –
Andrea Ventura – Francesca Viozzi – Zhaoying Zhu
workshop introduction
Three
buildings, although small in size but considered to be icons of modern
architecture, are located on the territory of the Municipality of
Roquebrune-Cap-Martin (Côte d'Azur): Villa E.1027 by Eileen Gray & Jean
Badovici, Le Corbusier Camping Units and its Cabanon. Linked by adjacent plots
and the history of their owners, these architectures perched on the coast are
distant from the old town, which is more than 220 meters above the Grande
Corniche road.
The
Conservatoire du Littoral has been the owner of these architectures since 2000,
with the financial support of the City of Roquebrune-Cap-Martin.
The
association Eileen Gray - Etoile de mer Le Corbusier, founded by Robert Rebutato in 2000, has
campaigned for the protection of the site and particularly supported the
restoration of Villa E.1027, also thanks to the creation of the Cap Moderne
Association, which manages the site and welcomes visitors to the station of
Roquebrune-Cap-Martin (district of Cabbé).
However,
the opening of Villa E.1027 to the public in 2015 highlighted some issues concerning
the creation of sustainable tourism meanwhile promoting the cultural heritage
which both require various actors (the Municipality, the Region, The coastline
Conservatory, cultural associations, etc.). The balance between sustainable
tourism and cultural heritage needs a more in-depth reflection, questioning the
future of the site and its integration into the main touristic networks and roads,
from the centre to the old town. In this sense, the workshop aims to explore
throughout the project of architecture and landscape, the relationship between
Tourism and Heritage in a perspective of cultural and economic enhancement of
the territory.
workshop program
The
city of Roquebrune Cap Martin is plural, especially concerning its history and
its topography. In fact, Roquebrune Cap Martin is composed by the ancient
village of Roquebrune, which is perched on the hills, and the city of
Cap-Martin, which follows the hill crest that divides the city into two coastal
fronts: the bay of Cabbé, oriented towards the west and looking towards Monaco,
and Carnolès, whose limits stretch towards the east as far as Menton. Two train
stations link the city: Roquebrune-Cap-Martin station at the west of Cap
Martin, and Carnolès station at the east. These two sides of the territory
offer the opportunity to rethink the polarities of the city, and to articulate
them throughout heritage components such as architecture, landscapes and
botanicals elements, among which there are: the E-1027 Villa by Eileen Gray
& Jean Badovici, the camping units and Cabanon by Le Corbusier, and the
opportunity given by the old Air Base 943 site, close to Carnolès station,
which is now in the process of being transformed, and illustrates the typical
landscape characteristics of the Mediterranean microclimate.
workshop sites
site 1 > habiter la
gare de Roquebrune-Cap-Martin: artistic units
The railway that links Monaco to Menton creates a
physical limit between the coast and the heights on which the old village is
perched, at 220 meters above the sea-level, accessible only by steep steps.
Moreover, the Roquebrune-Cap-Martin train station is difficult to access by the
departmental road (medium corniche). To cross the railway, pedestrians can use
an underground passage, meanwhile cars get through a first bridge that links
each side of the railway, and a second bridge that links the two car parking of
the train station. Partially decommissioned, the train station is composed of
under-exploited buildings, except the main hall which was recently transformed
into an exhibitions hall by the association Cap Moderne. Indeed, with the
recent opening of the E-1027 Villa, the station has acquired a special status
since it serves a remarkable site that combines sustainable tourism and
valorisation of the cultural heritage. A temporary reception hall and a shop
have been set up to welcome the visitors of «Cap Moderne» site. Therefore, it
is important to reinforce and qualify the reception of passenger-tourists arriving
at this station.
site 2 > habiter la
gare de Carnolès: seasonal units
Carnolès railroads also create a relief distinctive
boundary of the city. Indeed, the railroads follow a slope and clearly separate
the city into two sides, from the residential coast to the main city, whose
centrality is marked by the departmental road that crosses the city on the
mid-coast road and connects it to Monaco, Menton, and Italy on the opposite
direction. A small market place forms a diverticulum on this road. There are
very few under-rail passages connecting the two parts of the city of Carnolès.
Moreover, there are no real public spaces, opened places or signifying esplanades,
underlining the lack of centrality but suggesting a polarity. It should be
noted that the town hall is located on the crest hill, overviewing the two
bays. The existing station is made of temporary shelters for travellers with no
qualitative reception. In tangency to the railroads, the old Air Base 943 site,
which is in the process of being transformed, offers a real opportunity to take
advantage of some of its spaces to rethink the entire station, its centrality
and its functionality, both at the scale of the city and the territory of
Roquebrune Cap-Martin.
the goals
site 1 > Habiter la
Gare de Roquebrune-Cap-Martin: artistic units
The
reactivation of the station building and its adjoining spaces, such as the hall
and the parking areas, offers the possibility of a new program related to the
remarkable heritage of the area. This process may involve the creation of
experimental space for workshops and ateliers organized by schools of
architecture, design or art, renewing in a contemporary way the experimental
spirit of the site initiated by its pioneers E. Gray, J. Badovici and Le
Corbusier.
site 2 > habiter la
gare de Carnolès: seasonal units
It
would be interesting to take advantage of the upgrading of the train stop to transform
it into a multimodal station, combining train, bus, car park, electric bicycles
and facilitating the connections and the circulation on the territory. Adjacent
to the train station of Carnolès, the released area of the old Air Base 943
offers the possibility of such urban space. Some of the BA943 buildings can be
demolished, in order to release more space for the multimodal pole. Some other
buildings can be reused for educational programs related to design and
landscape education. The Botanical heritage must be considered, because some existing
species are quite significant in the BA943 area. Following the works of
Ferdinand Bac which inspired the Mexican architect Luis Barragan, the living
heritage of the site must be enhanced as well as the attractive outside areas
and park for locals and tourists, in order to stimulate a dynamic interaction
and learning spaces. The released open area of the station can be used as
experimental space by the students (or guest artists) of the School of
Landscape of the Mediterranean. A Hotel Management School can be also planned
on the site directly connected to tourism activities. In addition to this
double educational program, a main residential program may be associated, such
as student housing that in summer can be possibly turned into tourist accommodation.
workshop projects
(click the images to
enlarge)
Connexion culturelle
students Carmen
Fernandez, Zoé Lefèvre, Benedetta Savina,
Maisa Trindade, Andrea Ventura
Mind the Cap. Ecrire la lumière
students Jules
Balmes, Macarena Diéz, Matilde Nardi, Isabella Nylund,
Julian Rosenfeld
Construire la topographie
students Filippo Dottor, Marica
Giommarini, Rafael Luque, Manuel Muñoz,
Hugo Pires, Alejandra Rios, Zhaoying Zhu
Restanque City Project
students Desirée Borella, Joseph De
Metz, Francesca Mottin,
Anastassia Rouchy, Adrian Suarez Torres, Francesca
Viozzi
Crossing Promenade to the Horizon
students Clement Bonnet, Maria
Lorenza Crupi, Alessandra Guglielmo,
Inès Pradeau, Francisca Queiroz
Inter Section
students Ana Paula Benitez Coquet,
Francisco De La Rosa,
Morgane Gernigon, Maria Laura Leonardi, Bogdan Ursan